Western Boot Sizing: How Cowboy and Cowgirl Boots Should Actually Fit

A pair of western boots should fit close to your usual shoe size, but they will feel different to your everyday sneakers. While they usually have a firm instep, more room around the toes and a little lift at the heel, any pinching, numbness or your foot sliding means the fit is off.

Learning how to size cowboy boots can help save you trying to break in a pair that may not be the ones for you. Before buying western boots, use these tips to find your size and know what should settle after a few wears.

Do Western Boots Run Big or Small?

Okay first things first, do cowboy boots run big or small? For the most part, you should be able to pick your usual shoe size, paying attention to the width, instep and toe shape.

• Square-toed western boots will usually have more room across the front.
• A round toe sits closer to the foot.
• Pointed toes have a longer tip your toes aren’t meant to fill.
• Wide-fit western boots give you more room across the foot without adding any length.

So, are cowboy boots true to size then? For the most part, yes, but always check if the label uses AU or US sizing before choosing your usual number and any fit styles like those above.

How Should Cowgirl Boots Fit?

Women’s cowgirl boots should be firm in the instep without feeling crowded in the toes or any slipping. When you’re trying boots on, make sure you have the socks you plan to wear with them and walk around, paying attention to the: 

• Ball of the foot, making sure it sits at the widest part of the sole so the boot bends naturally as you walk.
• Instep, looking for a firm feeling without pinching, numbness or heavy pressure across the top of the foot.
• Toes, ensuring they lie flat and don’t hit the front when you walk.
• Heel, expecting a small lift while the rest of your foot stays in place.

Remember: they won’t feel like sneakers. Leather boots also soften and conform to your feet the more you wear them, getting comfier with time if they’re a solid fit.

Why Heel Slip Is Normal

If you’re used to lace-up boots, the little bit of movement in western boots can feel strange. In new cowgirl boots, around 6 mm, or a quarter-inch, of lift is completely normal, although the sole will start out feeling stiffer and not bend fully with your step. This will relax a bit with time and wear.

Signs your western boots fit or are too loose:

A little movement doesn’t always mean you need to go down a size. If you go too small, you may find your toes push forward or the ball of your foot is out of place, creating different problems. Many people find wearing a thicker sock can help while they break in and get used to the fit and style.

Should You Size Up in Western Boots?

Usually not, as sizing up adds length, which can leave your foot sliding around without fixing the problem. New boots can also feel a bit firmer, but the leather can soften up and shape to your foot, or a specialist may be able to stretch them out a bit. 

However, the boots shouldn’t be painful, even brand new. Noticing any numbness, crushed toes or serious pressure when you walk likely means you need to try another size or shape. 

How half sizes can help. 

Instead of a full size up, choosing a half size can be an option to consider if you have a high instep, a wider foot or plan to wear thick socks with your boots. Like any other size, the ball of your foot should still stay in place and you shouldn’t experience any sliding.

Calf Width, Shaft Height and Australian vs US Sizing

Your shoe size is also just one part of picking out western boots. Before ordering women’s boots or men’s boots, also check how the shaft will sit around your leg. 

Start by measuring around the widest part of your calf and where the top of the boot will sit. Also measure with your socks on. Taller boot shafts will reach higher on the calf, so they may also have a closer fit around the leg. 

Ringers Western Boot Size Chart

The Ringers Western size guide is in US sizing, with women’s US and AU sizing matching. Our men’s US sizing is one number higher than AU standard sizing. Sizing may also vary between styles.

Remember to measure both feet.

When you’re measuring your feet and calves for boots, make sure you measure each one leg and foot, using the larger of the two. Also measure later in the day while you’re wearing your usual boot socks. This is when your feet are their largest, making sure your boots will be more comfortable throughout the day as your feet swell. 

To make measuring easier, stand on a piece of paper and mark your heel and longest toe, and then measure the distance between them.

Getting the Size Right First Time

When your boots arrive, take a few laps around the house, looking out for:

• A firm hold across the instep
• Enough room for your toes (give them a wiggle)
• The ball of your foot sitting at the widest point
• A little heel lift without your foot sliding forward

Your usual shoe size is a good starting point, making sure to convert it in the size chart, if needed, and checking for any fit differences between styles. Shop women’s boots and men’s boots with your measurements ready.